Semin takes shot at Crosby

Canwest News Service

Published: Friday, October 31, 2008

Washington Capitals forward Alexander Semin is emerging from the shadows of Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin and teammate Alex Ovechkin.

Alexander Semin #28 of the Washington Capitals looks on against the Philadelphia Flyers at Wachovia Center October 1, 2008 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.

Alexander Semin #28 of the Washington Capitals looks on against the Philadelphia Flyers at Wachovia Center October 1, 2008 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.

Photograph by : Getty Images

ARTICLE TOOLS

Font:
AddThis Social Bookmark Button

But Semin, who is tied with Malkin atop the National Hockey League in scoring race with 16 points, isn't much of a fan of Malkin's Pittsburgh Penguins' teammate.

"What's so special about (Crosby)? I don't see anything special there," Semin said in an interview with Yahoo.com. "Yes, he does skate well, has a good head, good pass. But there's nothing else. Even if you compare him to Patrick Kane from Chicago . . . (Kane) is a much more interesting player. The way he moves, his deking abilities, his thinking on the ice and his anticipation of the play is so superb."

Crosby, 21, has become the face of the NHL since he was drafted first overall by the Penguins in the 2005 entry draft.

The fourth-year centreman scored 39 goals and 63 assists in his first season, then won the scoring title and was named the league's most valuable player in his sophomore year when he scored 36 goals and 84 assists.

This season, Crosby, a native of Cole Harbour, N.S.,  has scored three goals and 10 assists in 11 games.

"I think that if you take any player, even if he is dead wood, and start promoting him, you'll get a star," Semin told the website. "Especially if he scores 100 points. No one is going to care about anyone else. No one is going to care whether he possesses great skill.

"Let's say you put someone in front of the net and let him deflect pucks in, and he scored 50 goals, everyone will say 'Wow!' and then hand him a $10 million-per-year contract. That's what they like here."

Semin, 24, is in his fourth season with the Capitals.

He made his debut in 2003-04 when he scored 10 goals and 12 assists in 52 games. After two seasons playing in his native Russia, he returned to the Capitals in 2006-07 when he scored 38 goals and 35 assists in 77 games.

Last season, he had 26 goals and 16 assists in 63 games.

"In Russia people like beautiful hockey, and not dump and chase," Semin told Yahoo!. "I just don't get it, why when a player is skating up the ice and no one is attacking him, he dumps the puck into the offensive zone and then chases it? Why would you do this if there is no one forechecking you?

"I understand that if there is someone coming at you and you don't know whether you can get past that player, then you can dump the puck, pass it or shoot. But if not, then hold on to the puck, skate forward, create a chance. Why would you want to dump the puck and then chase after it and crash into the boards? I don't know. But that's just my opinion."

 
 
 
 
 

your comments
Don't like it
Fri, Oct 31, 08 at 12:01 PM
I don't care for what Semin is saying. Crosby has won scoring titles and already lead his team to a Stanley Cup final and trust me he can do more than just pass. Honestly the only knock against Crosby is that he appears to be injury prone. I think Mr. Semin is developing a little "Super Ego" just because he's off to a fast start.
llama
Fri, Oct 31, 08 at 12:14 PM
Semin is right. Crosby is a diving, whining player who gets 'superstar treatment' from the refs. Crosby is a disgrace to the game.
SEMIN CLOUDED MY JUDGEMENT
Fri, Oct 31, 08 at 12:45 PM
this is Alexander Semin here, you must dicard this passage, i said this after taking a hit that left me a little wooozzey, because you see when i was 19 i was still in Russia just about to be drafted, when Crosby was 19 he led the ENTIRE NHL in scoring, which i have yet to do and im 24. He is the best player in the NHL and proves it night in and out with his dedication, constant effort, unmatched skill, and his calmness on and off the ice. If i can ever become half the player he is and/or will be i will be satisfied with my career. They didnt name him the "next one" because they fell into the hype, that is just an uneducated statement.
Mike
Fri, Oct 31, 08 at 12:50 PM
Say what you are REALLY thinking Alex. LOL.
Lisa
Fri, Oct 31, 08 at 01:11 PM
What an idiot! Go back to Russia...
shaune
Fri, Oct 31, 08 at 01:14 PM
Semin? Semin? I think Semin might be getting a little carried away with his early sucess. Crosby is by far the best player in the hockey world. Let's just see who leads the league at the end of the year.
Rob
Fri, Oct 31, 08 at 01:24 PM
Young, dumb & full of Semin.
Matt Roberts
Fri, Oct 31, 08 at 01:38 PM
Did he just insult north american hockey? We only like dump & chase? We don't like beautiful hockey? Im pretty sure our canadian kid crosby has put on some of the most beautiful moves seen in the last 20 years. Keep carrying the puck across the blueline semin, just make sure you keep your head up. You couldn't lace Crosby's skates.
nan
Fri, Oct 31, 08 at 01:47 PM
Go back to Russi then Semin--we don't want you here!
nan
Fri, Oct 31, 08 at 01:47 PM
Go back to Russia then Semin--we don't want you here!
Nori from Toronto!!
Fri, Oct 31, 08 at 02:13 PM
Wow, can you say JEALOUS?!?!? Im sure he would loooove to be in Sidney's shoes and be the face of the NHL!! Having said that, Sidney not only possesses great skill and has a focused mind but it's his personality, his morals, work ethic and his traits that make him so likeable. He is an all around nice guy who is well mannered and knows how to be diplomatic in situations. That is why they chose him. With comments like Semin's, do you really think kids are going to look up to him? He sounds like a future Sean Avery to me. Seriously, he needs to check himself before making comments like that about anyone. That's just my opinion.
on the fence
Fri, Oct 31, 08 at 02:15 PM
Although I don't agree with everything Semin said, I've never been a Crosby fan. He's a good player, but I don't see how he's comparable to the hockey greats that people seem to lump him in with. I'd much rather have OV than Crosby. In my mind, Crosby and Tiger Woods are the same, in that they are both really good at their sports, they both have that same boyish, pouty look on their faces all the time, and neither one really has a personality. Well, at least Tiger speaks his mind on occasion, instead of the usual cliches that Crosby spits out every day. But honestly, hardly anyone really knows or cares about Semin at this point in his career, and he has no business saying what he said.
Doug
Fri, Oct 31, 08 at 02:56 PM
Semin in english is idiot!
Canada's game
Fri, Oct 31, 08 at 03:03 PM
"In russia we run in meadows, chase butterflies and play beautiful hockey" Get out of here. There's a KHL contract with your name on it figure skater.
Endernil
Fri, Oct 31, 08 at 03:06 PM
Wow! People are constantly complaining because all they ever hear from athletes are platitudes. Then, when one speaks his mind, the nuts start falling off the internet posting tree en masse. Sheesh. --- As for you NAN, when you say "Go back to Russia then Semin--we don't want you here!", who the hell exactly is "we"? Are you the one who now speaks for all Canadian hockey fans? Must be a tough gig - how's the pay?
Truth
Fri, Oct 31, 08 at 03:26 PM
Crosby is not the best player in the NHL. Admittedly he is a good player, but please be realistic. Saying that he has made the best plays and goals in the last 20 years is simply not true. You look at any top ten goals scored from a season and you'll be pressed to find crosby in one of them since you came to NHL. Semin is right, hockey here is alot of dump and chase, hockey fights and big hits. I'd love to see more "beautiful" hockey but its scarce. You look at most of the goals scored and they mostly just in front of the net, banging one in, or roofing it. But rarely do you see a team take the puck from their own blue line make pass after pass and then easily putting it in the back of the net. The nhl right now is focused more on the tough aspect of the game and hitting than anything else. You just have to look at the % of hockey fights in the last 5 years to know they are increasing rapidly. I just wish semin played for the oil. And all you fans of crosby, there are alot of better 2 way players in the nhl than crosby, and better goal scorers. You just have to look at the stats
Yzermanwastheman
Fri, Oct 31, 08 at 03:43 PM
Best 5 forwards in the NHL: 1-Alex Ovechkin 2-Evgeni Malkin 3-Sidney Crosby 4-Jerome Iginla 5-Vinny Lecavalier That being said the point is that Semin is saying Crosby is overrated, which I agree with. Semin never said he was a better player, which would be absolutle untrue. Get a grip all of you xenophobes, just because he says Crosby is overrated it isn't an insult to Canada or a compliment to Russia.
B-Watts
Fri, Oct 31, 08 at 03:47 PM
I'll be damned if Crosby isn't one of the top 3 players in the NHL. Semin is on crack. Europeen hockey and particualrly the now defunct super ligue are now well known to be the home of clutch and grab hockey. Maybe that's because the NHL depleats them of their best talent, maybe its because it takes more talent to play the big ice game in an entertaining fashion. For whatever reason Russian players have taken to looking down their noses at North Americans but Sidney plays Russian puck possesion style hockey as well as he plays the smash mouth North American game. Same goes for Ovechkin. Their ability to syncretize the styles is what makes them the best. Oh well, at the end of their careers I'm sure Crosby will be the more highly regarded of the two. You can bet your bottom dollar on it. Oh and TRUTH, you need to watch more Habs and Red Wings games apparently.
Jeff
Fri, Oct 31, 08 at 03:55 PM
Gretzky, Howe, Richard, Lecavalier, Iginla, Beliveau, Lafleur, Glenn Anderson, Paul Coffey, Ray Bourque, Joe Sakic, Bobby Orr, Gilbert Perrault etc. These were the greatest players of their genration and the most popular. Who says Canadians don't love beautiful hockey. Frankly, with the exception of Ovechkin, Malkin and Datsyuk, todays best players are almost invariably Canadian. Bergeron, Lecalvalier, Brad Richards, Sam Gagner and Andrew Cogliano, The Stahl brothers etc, these are the young stars who will dominate the league for years to come and they are all Canadian.
Lance
Fri, Oct 31, 08 at 04:18 PM
YESSS!!! finally someone with some sense! good job Semin! I am from Nova Scotia myself and I have been tired of hearing of that non talented weak player. hes not what a canadian hockey player is all about, hes a pussy and has everything handed to him. doesnt matter he'll be out of the leage b4 long anyways cause hes the weakest player out there, he'll have so many injuries he'll be forced to retire. I'm soo glad other players around the leage are realizing he's 100% hype and not a good canadian romodel
joe jim
Fri, Oct 31, 08 at 04:26 PM
other then assists, what does crosby do??? yea i didnt think he did anything else, so how does that make u the best? maybe if he'd hit and fight and stick up for his teammates like real canadians do he'd have my respect but he's weaker then a european
Pat - Vaughan
Fri, Oct 31, 08 at 04:54 PM
Semin must mean clued out in Russian. Patrick Kane looks like he's going to be a good one too ... but I think he will be a notch below Crosby's level. At least we know Semin will never be a GM after his playing career. He has no clue what an all around solid player is. It's not just about making the hi-lite reels.
Josh
Fri, Oct 31, 08 at 05:00 PM
Totally right!
Joe
Fri, Oct 31, 08 at 06:02 PM
Semin stop complaining, just because Crosby has three times as much talent as you will ever have doesn't give you any right to be mad. And if you would like to get your facts straight Crosby does lug the puck in the zone he rarely dumps and chases. He also hits people and is a leader and is probably the best player in the nhl at protecting the puck. If you like Russia so much then you can go back there and play.
lol
Fri, Oct 31, 08 at 06:03 PM
I would just like to remind everyone that when a game of hockey is played, two teams are competing for points in the standings; they do not care if it looks pretty, they care about winning. If the team wants to play tight defence, dump and chase to punish your D all night, wearing them down like a football strategy, that's their choice. When it comes down to it, pretty hockey doesn't count if you're getting knocked out of the playoffs like Montreal was by Philly last year.
Note*
Fri, Oct 31, 08 at 06:05 PM
Also note, that it was Philly who knocked out the Capitals, and that Philly was beaten by Sid the (whinney) Kid and his icebirds.
Annie
Fri, Oct 31, 08 at 06:09 PM
I think Sidney Crosby must get sick of hearing about Sidney Crosby.
Joe
Fri, Oct 31, 08 at 06:47 PM
He left out Crosby's diving. And his whining. Otherwise: Spot on.
deathbyemu
Fri, Oct 31, 08 at 07:05 PM
Spot on? Dope. Just because Sid doesn't spend 2/3 of a game out of position chasing a rival, risking his own teams success and his own health (Like Semin's big boyfriend) doesn't mean he isn't a special player. I have never heard anything as stupid as Semin saying 'any piece of dead wood can score a hundred points'. What a moronic statement. Just what does that make all of the grinders, d-men, agitators, and goalies out there who don't have a chance of sniffing 100 points? (that includes Semin himself) Guy playes Robin to Batman A.O., and rides his coat tail to a good year and now he thinks he's Grets or something. Keep your mouth shut and score your hundred points, Captain Special. Then maybe you can open your mouth.
ahmed
Fri, Oct 31, 08 at 07:55 PM
semin has and does not have a point. valid points semin has made is that many people possess a skill set similar to that of crosby's but have not been gifted with the assets that crosby has been granted (malkin, gonchar, whitney to name a few), and has made his way to the top. also the "beautiful hockey" part. i think that the style crosby plays is a soft, whiny, unwilling strategy, while people such as semin and ovechkin put their souls in their play and try to create chances rather than waiting up for their team. anyone who can create a play like that posesses TRUE skill. however, great players always find a way to succeed, and crosby has found that. crosby has accomplished so much in his career already at the age of 21, and even though he has been granted various assets, he has made use of them. crosby is an amazing player, but like any human, he has bad qualities
Rob
Fri, Oct 31, 08 at 08:20 PM
Then go back to Russia, Beutiful Hockey? We like men here not geeks.
nice try
Fri, Oct 31, 08 at 08:59 PM
why make an article that just repeats what the original article said? o that's right, you just wanted a chance to stick up for your canadien "golden boy" and include their stats to make it seem like semin has no right to call out crosby's STYLE OF PLAY. what their stats have to do with style of play is beyond me. thanks for adding nothing new.
Llama
Fri, Oct 31, 08 at 11:29 PM
crosby should go to russia... he definitely plays like a russian the way he dives.
Bubba
Sat, Nov 1, 08 at 02:08 AM
What a complete dork ! Who is Alexander Semin anyways ?
Semensucks
Sat, Nov 1, 08 at 02:13 AM
Crosby already has a Hart Trophy, a Scoring Title and led his young team to the Cup Final and he is only 21 years old. Please remind me as to what has Semen done ?
hahahahaha
Sat, Nov 1, 08 at 07:28 AM
wow Semin is a moron. crosby is clearly one of the best in the league and deserves to be the face of the league because of his stats at a young age and his marketability...which Semin has neither of. pretty funny article on the whole.
Carmie Wilhelm
Sat, Nov 1, 08 at 10:47 AM
Perhaps, Semin is talking about His team mate Ovechkin and using Crosby as his whpping boy. He can always go back to Russia if he doesn't like our style of play. Besides that, he;s not too smart.
Andy
Sat, Nov 1, 08 at 12:16 PM
Once Semin gets as many points as Crosby he can talk.
Habs4ever
Sat, Nov 1, 08 at 12:34 PM
Semin is so right, the russian hockey player are dominating the NHL and there is not much talk about it. We just hear about Crosby!! Yes he produces a lot of points, but I rather se Malkin, Ovie, Semin or Datsyuk that are much more spectacular and more fun to watch.
The Dave
Sat, Nov 1, 08 at 12:48 PM
Hey Semin, you're 24. What were you doing when you were 19? Trying to figure out how to skate? While you were doing that, Sid won the NHL scoring titled and won the Lester Pearson as the NHL best player as voted by his peers......you know the players who play in the NHL. Semin can you say his peers think he is the best player. Can you say since you were in the NHL at 18 you have been playing against the other teams best shut down players? Can you say since your were in the NHL at 18 you've been getting hit, grabbed, mauled every nite and still be what he is. Of course not, while Sid was playing against men at 18, you were trying figure how to pay with the boys. I think you should go back to Russia and play beautiful hockey as you call it you wimp.
Hockeylover
Sat, Nov 1, 08 at 03:34 PM
I like Semin's comments. The NHL is getting boring. Too much dump and chase and not enough real talk from the players. As for who is the best, hard to say when every team plays a system and if you step outside it your benched. No creativity anymore. I miss the Gretzky Oilers era when scores sometimes reached double digits and players still screwed up. A bit of a ramble starting here. Bottom line, I'd rather be out playing shinny then watching and listening to any of these overpayed primadonnas. The best games of hockey are still played at 11:oo p.m. in the local rink.
AC87
Mon, Nov 3, 08 at 07:16 PM
Ok Alexander Semin, I actually don't really see his comments being worth saying. Yes, Crosby is the face of the Nhl and I'm sure Semin is upset that he's not but to sy that Crosby just has a good head, good pass and skates well is HUGE understatement!! Yes he posesses those three qualities as well as leadership, puck handling and he's an all around amazing hockey player. I'm sure Semin is upset that he doesnt score 100+ points a season and that Crosby is the face of Reebok/NHL and Crosby lead his team to the Stanley cup last year before the age of 21. Yeah Semin, check your information man because your all wrong. Then again it is your opinion but your completely wrong.
Pens
Wed, May 13, 09 at 09:45 PM
Series over, do you still think that Semmy??
PensFan
Sun, Aug 30, 09 at 01:14 PM
You're all just jealous loosers! Even if Crosby got ring that happened because of Malkin. He pulled Pens to playoff, not Crosby. And Crosby's faded game is illustration to Semin's words. However NHL bosses are trying to make Crosby the symbol of NHL, Ovechkin and Malkin are much more popular, much more talented. Who the hell cares about Crosby?
Add Your Comment
 
Your Name
 
Your Comment
 
 
The Rules:
 
Keep it clean, and stay on the subject or we might delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. You must have a javascript enabled browser to submit a comment.
 
 
 

Who is Canada's biggest threat?

Dave Waddell and Elliott Pap go head2head.

 
 
 
 
 
 
 

past head2head

 

Debating the deals

Wayne Scanlan and George Johnson go head2head.

 

Canadiens goalie situation...

Dave Stubbs and Pat Hickey go head2head.

 

Two views on head injuries...

Cam Cole and John MacKinnon go head2head.