Canucks have big decision to make if Wellwood wins today's ruling

Gordon Mcintyre, The Province

Published: Tuesday, July 28, 2009

It was the first shot across the bow, albeit done in jest. But Canucks GM Mike Gillis evoked the Kyle Wellfed image of last September when, responding to a question from state-of-the-union dinner emcee Barry McDonald earlier this summer, Gillis cracked that he knew for sure that Kyle Wellwood liked to eat.

ARTICLE TOOLS

Font:
AddThis Social Bookmark Button

It broke up the room and was obviously said tongue-in-cheek, but it was a reminder that at today's arbitration hearing between the club and Wellwood, shots will be taken.

The most famous exchange between management and players at these rare hearings came when Brian Burke was GM and Brendan Morrison was centring the West Coast Express, with Markus Naslund and Todd Bertuzzi on his high-flying wings.

"His agent tried to say Brendan was the 'straw that stirred the drink,'" Burke said to laughter at a past state-of-the-union, held to give season-ticket holders a chance to hear management and coaches speak in a light-hearted setting.

What Burke didn't add was the Canucks, at the Morrison hearing, had told a parable about a mouse crossing a river on the back of an elephant, then taking equal credit for the crossing.

Morrison, of course, was supposed to be the mouse.

We don't know what will be said today at Wellwood's hearing.

The Canucks offered a slight increase on his salary of $997,500 last season; Wellwood wants more.

If the Canucks don't like the arbitrator's ruling, the team could walk away and Wellwood would be a free agent.

Below are five reasons the Canucks should walk -- and five reasons they shouldn't.

TALENT:

On the one hand: Wellwood is an elite puck-handler, he sees the ice as well as anyone, has great hand-eye coordination and he can slow down the game, calming things for his excited teammates.

On the other hand: He worked his way off the second line to the third and even some fourth-line duty, with seven healthy scratches thrown in.

FITNESS:

On the one hand: Wellwood, partly with the help of a Canucks cook making meals for him earlier last season, worked hard (for him, anyway) on conditioning. This gave him up to 18:30 of ice time in the playoffs.

On the other hand: It's become part of local folklore, Pudge Wellwood appearing at training camp looking more like the Pillsbury Doughboy than Drew Doughty, being sent away by Alain Vigneault to train for a second/final physical. Wellwood got fitter, but in October was placed on waivers for the second time in four months. This time no one claimed him and he was planning to play in Russia before a Pavol Demitra rib injury created an open spot for him on the roster.

CONSISTENCY:

On the one hand: Wellwood had six goals in his first eight games after he rejoined the club for an Oct. 13 game. He had 13 by Boxing Day (31 games), including eight on the power play. In the playoffs, he became a playmaker again, notching six points in 10 games. He had the club's highest winning percentage in the faceoff circle (57.7)

On the other hand: The centre had a 21-game goalless stretch and scored just five goals after Boxing Day. And, although known as a set-up man over his spotted career, he had just nine assists in 74 regular-season game.

DEFENCE:

On the one hand: After an autumn epiphany, Wellwood embraced two-way play to the point that associate coach Rick Bowness was saying by season's end that Wellwood was "our best forward at coming down low and helping our defence break out. He has the ability to come in, sniff out the loose puck and he's so calm with it that he never throws it away, never turns it over."

On the other hand: Wellwood was minus-1 in the playoffs -- only four forwards were on the ice for more equal-strength goals by St. Louis and Chicago. He's slow and too small to be physical.

FIRE IN THE BELLY:

On the one hand: He's only 5-foot-10 and (depending on the time of year) 180 to 195 pounds, but shrugged off back-to-back high sticks to the face in the playoffs when, in the same game, Andrew Ladd high-sticked him above the eye and Patrick Kane slashed him in the mouth. Both penalties were four minutes, Ladd's requiring five stitches, Kane's resulting in a cut lip, a tooth knocked out and some spitting of blood. He's never been shy of going to get the puck off the boards or in the corners, either.

On the other hand: When Vigneault called him out at training camp, indeed when the coach singled him out throughout the campaign even to the point of scratching him from the lineup, Wellwood responded like a surfer dude shrugging his shoulders after his dad had bailed him out.

gordshockey@hotmail.com

 
 
 
 
 

your comments
BlogVader
Tue, Jul 28, 09 at 11:30 AM
uh ... Wellwood is a stiff. and it is pretty laughable that he is going to arbitartion. have you seen this guy play ? he flat out stinks.
Piojito
Tue, Jul 28, 09 at 11:52 AM
The out of shape stuff was trumped up by the club last year for use now during arbitration. This guy can play...the less head games the club employs the more productive he'll be - he's a smart kid. Let's see how smart Gillis is. After signing Raycroft I have my doubts.
Marco
Tue, Jul 28, 09 at 12:27 PM
If Scott Gomez can make almost $8 mil in todays NHL, Wellwood earning $1.5 mil is very reasonable. The Canucks are just trying to short-change Wellwood because they had to break the bank to put all that money in the pockets of the two sisters. No doubt it'll come back to bite them on the arse and they'll be stuck with those two playoff stiffs forever.
Clear Waivers
Tue, Jul 28, 09 at 01:00 PM
Remember this guy clearing waivers TWICE last year? For a reason you know. He will be another UFA, alongside his buddy Pylon. Maybe Burke will be interested!
Reality
Tue, Jul 28, 09 at 01:47 PM
Try to get a little perspective here. Marco says that since Gomez is over paid the Canucks should over pay Wellwood. Nice logic buddy. Also, to say that the bank was broken to pay the Sedins is a laugh considering they signed for less than market value. The sisters shtick is getting old. If you think that Wellwood is the answer, you should continue cheering for the leafs. Finally "oldimer" the Leafs are really improving? No top 6 forward talent and a team full of near goons who can't play. Have fun with all that. I guess Wayne Primeau is the answer. Burkie thought he was trading for Wayne Gretzky.
mlf
Tue, Jul 28, 09 at 01:49 PM
Primeau is another injured reserve write off, the draft pick is what it is really about. If Primeau ever does get well he is still could be a faceoff specialist which they haven't had since Mats wakled off into teh sunset.
Mickey
Tue, Jul 28, 09 at 02:06 PM
Wake up Burke another 4th line player to add to your stockpile
@ Reality
Tue, Jul 28, 09 at 11:34 PM
Hey REALITY, I wonder why the powers that be weren't lining up to sign the "sisters"? Guess most NHL GMs couldn't justify that option. You're the one who needs "a little perspective".
new ID
Wed, Jul 29, 09 at 05:27 AM
Having watched Wellwood as a leaf, I saw some talent.If he were to apply himself, I think he could be a 25-30 goal scorer and he would then get his 3-5 mil contract.
lonsmos
Wed, Jul 29, 09 at 10:26 AM
I agree he has a lot of talent but so far it seems to be wasted. In the new NHL he should be a star.
Rufus
Wed, Jul 29, 09 at 02:30 PM
as a coach I look for 3 points to determine a coachable player: a willingness to battle for the puck, the desire to get back into the play by skating hard into your own zone, rink awareness with and without the puck. After that it becomes team building and that takes time and a nurturing touch to work with different mental styles of individuals. Wellwood has worked and earned a place on this team. The criticisms have been way too generic. I don't understand why AV scratched him. He seems very coachable to me, with very good hands. What specifically led to the scratchings? AV's tough love approach is seems out of place with this player. Wellwood is more intelligent player when compared to many others but maybe it's that quieter softer-spoken intellect that irritates AV. If he was a loud mouthed goon maybe AV could relate better to him.
stuck on twins
Wed, Jul 29, 09 at 07:04 PM
Canux seem to do all they plannjing around the two Swedehearts and so far where have it got them? Wellwood int Messier but he's not asking for the key to the vault when you consider what some borderliners make today. Goons make 1.5 and most couldnt put a puck in a soccer net. Give the young lad a break.
@ reality
Wed, Jul 29, 09 at 07:15 PM
hey Reality you a real dorko, ya know? What good has the Swedeheart Sisters done the Canux anyrays? Dont bash Leafs cuz of you dont win the Cup you're just a wannabe and an also-ran and Canux aint won no cup so what are they?
Add Your Comment
 
Your Name
 
Your Comment
 
 
The Rules:
 
Keep it clean, and stay on the subject or we might delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. You must have a javascript enabled browser to submit a comment.
 
 
 

Who is Canada's biggest threat?

Dave Waddell and Elliott Pap go head2head.

 
 
 
 
 
 
 

past head2head

 

Debating the deals

Wayne Scanlan and George Johnson go head2head.

 

Canadiens goalie situation...

Dave Stubbs and Pat Hickey go head2head.

 

Two views on head injuries...

Cam Cole and John MacKinnon go head2head.