Canucks coach John Tortorella's classic misplay an unpopular decision

 

 
 
 
 
Clarke MacArthur #16 of the Ottawa Senators upends goalie Eddie Lack #31 of the Vancouver Canucks while crashing the net during the third period in NHL action on March 02, 2014 during the 2014 Tim Hortons Heritage Classic at BC Place Stadium.
 
 

Clarke MacArthur #16 of the Ottawa Senators upends goalie Eddie Lack #31 of the Vancouver Canucks while crashing the net during the third period in NHL action on March 02, 2014 during the 2014 Tim Hortons Heritage Classic at BC Place Stadium.

Photograph by: Rich Lam, Getty Images

More on This Story

 

VANCOUVER — John Tortorella said he gets it. I’m not so sure.

The Vancouver Canucks head coach said he gets what has gone on in this community with goaltenders the last few years. He gets the popularity Roberto Luongo has earned by handling it all -- the demotion to No. 2, the reincarnation, the contract, the Cory Schneider trade -- with rare aplomb.

He gets the angst it was certain to cause when he named NHL rookie Eddie Lack to make a third consecutive start after the Olympic break -- and not in just any hockey game, but in the Heritage Classic -- while the franchise goaltender sat in his touque on the end of the bench, opening and closing the door and trying to keep a neutral expression on his face for the TV closeups.

Tortorella turned an easy, no-fuss, no-muss choice that would never be second-guessed into an unnecessary kick in the private parts, an unpopular decision that had many in the crowd of 54,194 at B.C. Place Stadium booing Lack when his picture was flashed on the massive video board, and chanting “We want Lou!” when the Ottawa Senators’ winning goal went past Lack at 10:11 of the second period.

He said he didn’t hear the crowd.

He said he would make the same decision again.

He would take a starting goaltender, a 34-year-old, two-time Olympic gold medalist who is inextricably tied to this franchise for the forseeable future, and sit him out for three games after his return from Russia on the pretext that Eddie Lack was playing so well, he gave the Canucks the best chance to win.

He would take Roberto Luongo, who really wanted to play this indoor/outdoor specialty event -- a showcase, marquee occasion, surrounded by all the attendant pomp and nonsense the National Hockey League puts into these cash grabs -- and he would say, all over again: “No, Roberto, we like our chances better with Eddie.”

Really?

How does that play, do you think, in the dressing room, where Luongo is one of the two or three most important leaders, where his teammates knew how much he wanted to play?

John Tortorella says he gets that, too.

“I would like to think this is a veteran team, and this stuff here, I think you should be able to absorb as a veteran hockey club,” he said.

“This is part of the business. I have to make decisions, not on consensus, but on what I think is best for that team -- and Louie’s pissed. He’s not happy. He’s proud, and I get that. I like the guy. But this is part of the business.

“And I know this is a very sensitive thing here because of what happened last year, and I weighed that. But I have to make decisions, right now, on such short strokes, on what I think gives us the best chance to win. Eddie was playing lights-out. He has been very good all year long. He deserved to play this game.”

If only it were that simple.

What really happened Sunday, in the 4-2 loss to the Senators, was that he put both goalies in awkward positions; not no-win, precisely, but undeniably awkward.

Lack, Tortorella admitted, did not look himself either before or during the game, though he made some big saves.

But Eddie Lack cannot be the future of the franchise as long as Luongo is here, and that’s forever, apparently. So what is the upside now of dissing Luongo, in the stretch drive, for a club whose arc since the Stanley Cup final of 2011 has been a near-classic portrait of accelerating decline?

Tortorella was hired to halt that decline, to shock the team into a different gear. But the bounce hasn’t happened, and instead, we got the storming of the Calgary room, the suspension, the curious goaltending decision -- “curious” being a more polite way of saying “inane.” And results that are no better, and conceivably are a little worse, than might have been achieved with A. Vigneault and R. Bowness still running the bench.

The hope -- faint, admittedly -- was that there was some logical explanation we were all missing here.

That Luongo didn’t feel right yet, still bothered by jet lag, and like a certain journalist, was still falling asleep every day in the middle of the afternoon. Or that the Canucks’ sleep doctor had hooked him up to the K-Tel Super Sleep Deprivation Detector and determined that his biorhythms were all wrong for a 1 p.m. start five days after returning from Russia.

Or, alternatively, that this was some act of petty (yet, on a certain level, understandable) revenge on behalf of GM Mike Gillis or owner Francesco Aquilini for the comments Luongo made after the story emerged that Ryan Kesler wanted out of Vancouver.

“Whether he wants to go or stay, he’s not going anywhere,” Luongo said. “We all know how this script ends.”

It sounded bitter, and sarcastic, and heaven knows, if that’s what it was, Luongo ought to be entitled to at least one free shot without fear of retribution after two years of playing the good soldier while two coaches, a GM and an owner have batted his psyche around like a pinata.

Tortorella doesn’t see it that way.

“You guys make the call whether it was the right (choice), and you will, but I would make the same call (again),” Tortorella said.

Asked if he heard the crowd’s disenchanted reactions, the coach said he didn’t, but “that’s part of it. That’s part of being a pro, both for Louie and Eddie.”

Lack heard it.

“Yeah, I mean ... it’s their opinion. If they want to chant (for Lou), I’m OK with it. I just try to play the best I can out there,” said the tall Swede. “I know there’s a lot of talk around this game, I was just trying to focus on me and shut all that other part out. I thought I did a pretty good job of that, actually.”

Was he surprised to get the nod for this kind of showcase game? Maybe a little.

“I think it’s special to everybody. I get that. But I can’t make a decision where I don’t think I’m putting the best lineup out for that particular night because it’s special,” said Tortorella. “I know people are upset, I get that. But I can’t do it to make people happy. And I’m not going to.

“And I would do the same thing, and I think Louie is a pro enough to maybe even use it as motivation. However he wants to handle it, I think he’s going to handle it just fine.”

We’ll know soon enough.

ccole@vancouversun.com

 
 
 
Font:
 
 
 
 
Clarke MacArthur #16 of the Ottawa Senators upends goalie Eddie Lack #31 of the Vancouver Canucks while crashing the net during the third period in NHL action on March 02, 2014 during the 2014 Tim Hortons Heritage Classic at BC Place Stadium.
 

Clarke MacArthur #16 of the Ottawa Senators upends goalie Eddie Lack #31 of the Vancouver Canucks while crashing the net during the third period in NHL action on March 02, 2014 during the 2014 Tim Hortons Heritage Classic at BC Place Stadium.

Photograph by: Rich Lam, Getty Images

 
Clarke MacArthur #16 of the Ottawa Senators upends goalie Eddie Lack #31 of the Vancouver Canucks while crashing the net during the third period in NHL action on March 02, 2014 during the 2014 Tim Hortons Heritage Classic at BC Place Stadium.
Eddie Lack #31 of the Vancouver Canucks makes a glove save against the Ottawa Senators.
Daniel Sedin #22 of the Vancouver Canucks is helped to the dressing room by medical staff after getting hit in the second period.
Vancouver Canucks celebrate their first goal vs. Ottawa Senators.
Vancouver Canucks Jannik Hansen (right) is checked by Ottawa Senators #4 Chris Phillips.
Bobby Ryan #6 of the Ottawa Senators tries to get past Kevin Bieksa #3 of the Vancouver Canucks.
Jannik Hansen #36 of the Vancouver Canucks checks Cody Ceci #5 of the Ottawa Senators.
Vancouver Canucks Brad Richardson and Ryan Kesler in pre-game skate vs. Ottawa Senators.
Daniel Sedin #22 of the Vancouver Canucks lies on the ice behind goalie Craig Anderson #41 of the Ottawa Senators after taking a hit.
Cody Ceci #5 of the Ottawa Senators leaves the ice after the pre game warm up before NHL action.
Zack Kassian #9 of the Vancouver Canucks celebrates with Ryan Stanton #18 after scoring a goal against the Ottawa Senators.
Erik Karlsson #65 of the Ottawa Senators celebrates with Clarke MacArthur #16 after scoring a goal against the Vancouver Canucks.
Zack Kassian #9 of the Vancouver Canucks celebrates after scoring a goal against the Ottawa Senators.
Vancouver Canucks Zack Kassian (right) celebrates his goal with teammate Ryan Stanton.
Vancouver Canucks-Ottawa Senators during NHL Heritage Classic at BC Place Stadium.
Vancouver Canucks Chris Higgins celebrates the team’s first goal vs. Ottawa Senators and goalie Craig Anderson.
Clarke MacArthur #16 of the Ottawa Senators celebrates after scoring a goal against Vancouver Canucks.
Vancouver Canucks Chris Higgins celebrates the team’s first goal vs. Ottawa Senators and goalie Craig Anderson.
Clarke MacArthur #16 of the Ottawa Senators celebrates after scoring a goal against the Vancouver Canucks.
Vancouver Canucks left wing Alex Burrows (14) gets a push from Ottawa Senators defenceman Chris Phillips (4) during the third period of the Heritage Classic hockey game at BC Place in Vancouver, B.C. Sunday, March 2, 2014.
Vancouver Canucks Chris Higgins, left, tangles with Ottawa Senators Chris Phillips behind goalie Craig Anderson.
Daniel Sedin #22 of the Vancouver Canucks and Marc Methot #3 of the Ottawa Senators battle for the loose puck during the second period in NHL action on March 01, 2013 during the 2014 Tim Hortons Heritage Classic at BC Place Stadium.
Goalie Craig Anderson #41 of the Ottawa Senators misses the puck shot by Jason Garrison #5 of the Vancouver Canucks.
The Ottawa Senators and Vancouver Canucks shake hands after playing the Heritage Classic NHL game at BC Place stadium in Vancouver on Sunday March 2, 2014. Ottawa won 4-2.
 
 
 
 
 
 
We encourage all readers to share their views on our articles and blog posts. We are committed to maintaining a lively but civil forum for discussion, so we ask you to avoid personal attacks, and please keep your comments relevant and respectful. If you encounter a comment that is abusive, click the "X" in the upper right corner of the comment box to report spam or abuse. We are using Facebook commenting. Visit our FAQ page for more information.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Your voice
Did the Leafs make the right choice hiring an analytics-focussed GM?
 
Yes, it's about time.
No, they still need better players.
Only time will tell.
Don't know.