In search of a No. 1

So, who is the best player in the NHL? That's a matter of opinion

Jim Bray and James Madge, National Post

Published: Wednesday, October 08, 2008

2. Alexander Ovechkin Washington, left wing

Alex Ovechkin, Sidney Crosby and Nicklas Lidstrom were the brightest stars on this year's preview list.

Alex Ovechkin, Sidney Crosby and Nicklas Lidstrom were the brightest stars on this year's preview list.

Photograph by : Getty, Reuters, Ottawa Citizen

ARTICLE TOOLS

Font:
AddThis Social Bookmark Button

A Cup appearance is likely all that separates Alex the Great from Crosby. He collected four major awards at the end of last season (Hart, Pearson, Richard and Ross), and is the single most exciting player to watch. His passion is proving contagious for his Capitals teammates.

3. Nicklas Lidstrom Detroit, defenceman

Lidstrom might be 38 years old, but he seems to be in his prime. He has won six of the last seven Norris trophies, and was the runner-up the three previous seasons. Some worried about the Wings' leadership when Steve Yzerman departed. Lidstrom has answered any doubts.

4. Jarome Iginla Calgary, right wing

The man most likely to lead Canada at the 2010 Olympics can still score (50 goals and 98 points last season), and still fight (five majors) when he feels he has to. The Flames captain is a modern-day Gordie Howe. All that is missing is a parade on Calgary's Red Mile.

5. Henrik Zetterberg Detroit, left wing

The Swede's fortunes are often tied to that of his Russian linemate Pavel Datsyuk (they combined for 189 points last season), but a 27-point playoff effort en route to the Stanley Cup--and the Conn Smyth Trophy as the postseason MVP--helped create some separation.

6. Vincent Lecavalier Tampa Bay, centre

He was once heralded to be hockey's version of Michael Jordan, and while Lecavalier has not quite lived up to that hype, the former No. 1 draft pick knows how to drive to the net. He's big, fast and coming off a pair of 40-plus goal seasons (52 in 2006-07, 40 in 2008-09).

7. Pavel Datsyuk Detroit, centre

How is it that the man who led his team in scoring (97 points), assists (66) and plus/ minus (plus-41) gets ranked below two of his teammates? It is a problem only the Red Wings could have. The consistent Datsyuk has 271 points in 236 games since the NHL lockout.

8. Martin Brodeur New Jersey, goaltender

Pick a goalie, any goalie, to build your team around. For many, that has long been Brodeur. He has won three Cups and an Olympic gold medal, and been named the league's top goalie on four occasions. With a big game on the line, Brodeur's name is at the top of everyone's list.

9. Roberto Luongo Vancouver, goaltender

The NHL won't allow Luongo to be captain, but that doesn't mean he's not a leader. He finished in the top five in games played, shots against, shutouts and saves last season, and was in the top 10 in wins on a non-playoff team. Vancouver is no longer a goalie graveyard.

10. Joe Thornton San Jose, centre

When Thornton managed only 67 assists last season, it seemed like an off-year, but only by his standards. It was the first time in three seasons he had set up fewer than 90 goals. Thornton still led the league, and he finished in the top five in scoring for the fourth time in five years.

11. Evgeni Malkin Pittsburgh, centre

 
 
 
 
 

your comments
Patrick
Wed, Oct 8, 08 at 11:42 AM
Why is it that everyone hates on the Pacific??? Nabakov is by far the toughest goalie in the net. Old man winter is past his prime and should have retired four years ago. I do agree with Sid at number one though. He is an amazing player and will go very far in his career.
RICHARD Q
Wed, Oct 8, 08 at 02:44 PM
right now zetterberg is a better player than crosby. he is a better two way player
Thomas
Thu, Oct 9, 08 at 09:31 AM
Interesting that a team (Montreal) that is heavily favoured to, at least, compete for a final berth has only an honourable mention in Kovalev.
Alexis
Thu, Oct 9, 08 at 11:31 PM
Yeah but Montreal is all about depth. They get scoring from a lot of different people and Andrei Markov is underrated
Add Your Comment
 
Your Name
 
Your Comment
 
 
The Rules:
 
Keep it clean, and stay on the subject or we might delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. You must have a javascript enabled browser to submit a comment.
 
 
 

Who is Canada's biggest threat?

Dave Waddell and Elliott Pap go head2head.

 
 
 
 
 
 
 

past head2head

 

Debating the deals

Wayne Scanlan and George Johnson go head2head.

 

Canadiens goalie situation...

Dave Stubbs and Pat Hickey go head2head.

 

Two views on head injuries...

Cam Cole and John MacKinnon go head2head.