GM's dithering creates complications

Damien Cox, The Toronto Star

Published: Thursday, October 23, 2008

Brian Burke has, effectively, given the Anaheim Ducks notice.

Brian Burke.

Brian Burke.

Photograph by : Getty Images

ARTICLE TOOLS

Font:
AddThis Social Bookmark Button

By not signing the contract extension he's had in his mitts for months, he's made it clear he has little or no intention of signing it without actually saying so to Anaheim fans and the general public.

Meanwhile, by indicating this week that he intends to "make a decision" by Christmas, he's basically told the Ducks that by that date he won't be willing to pretend any more.

He wants out.

The Ducks wouldn't release him as he asked last spring, or at least give him permission to talk to other clubs. But soon that won't be their call any longer.

That, of course, will put the Ducks and team president Michael Schulman in a dicey predicament. When Burke tells them during the holiday season that he won't be agreeing to a new contract - only a major change of circumstances would change that now - Schulman will be left with the problem of having a lame duck GM heading towards the trade deadline and, after that, the draft and free agency.

If the Ducks, even with owner Henry Samueli possibly heading to the big house next summer, are rolling through the Western Conference, that won't be as big a problem.

But what if they're playing the way they are now?

At 2-5, these Ducks just don't look very much like the team that won it all two seasons ago. Sure, they beat the Maple Leafs in a shootout Tuesday, but they were outshot 28-4 over the second half of the game and seemed to basically fall asleep after jumping ahead 2-0 in the first.

"It just seems like a switch turns off for us," said head coach Randy Carlyle.

The Ducks held the lead into the final minute of play, but then lazily iced the puck, with Anton Stralman of the Leafs easily outskating Corey Perry to get the faceoff in the Anaheim zone.

With Vesa Toskala out for a sixth attacker, the Ducks called a timeout to organize their defence and sent out their most reliable veterans. But the Leafs easily swarmed the visitors and Matt Stajan missed a wide-open net moments before Nik Antropov buried a rebound for his second goal of the game to send the match into OT.

"Most of the guys that are here now were here when we won the Cup," said goalie Jean-Sebastien Giguere. "We know what it takes."

Burke has said he will wait until Nov.1 to evaluate his club before considering major changes. While the guts of the Ducks remain the same, there have been a lot of changes over the past 18 months with the support personnel. Dustin Penner and Andy McDonald were significant players for Anaheim who left, while spare parts like Drew Miller, Joe DiPenta and Ryan Shannon were helpful players as well.

The complication, of course, is that if Burke decides to start re-working his roster but isn't committed to the Ducks beyond this season, it creates an awkward perception for everyone involved.

Schulman believed he needed to force Burke to stay for the health of the team, but now the health of the team might end up suffering because Burke has been forced to stay.

For the Maple Leafs, meanwhile, the search committee headed by Gord Kirke is still operating, but at a very low level. Burke, Ken Holland of Detroit and Doug Wilson of the San Jose Sharks are believed to be three GMs coveted by the Leafs and the first to spring free would likely get the job.

If that's Burke in January, then he could be heir to the throne soon after. But if he can't come before the summer, then Cliff Fletcher is in the lame-duck position, left with critical and complicated winter personnel decisions.

This Burke-to-the-Leafs story stopped being uncomplicated a long time ago.

 
 
 
 
 

your comments
Johnnie Oil
Thu, Oct 23, 08 at 10:48 AM
Good luck to the leafs with this guy! He got lucky in Anahiem to win the cup and has shown what a bozo he really is with the recent comments on K. Lowe. But he is the media darling of TSN and other sports media so he will be a good fit in TO and firmly keep the leafs from winning the cup anytime soon.
Will.i.am
Thu, Oct 23, 08 at 11:46 AM
I think Burke is a knowledgeable GM, but I think I would rather Doug Wilson or Ken Holland come aboard. And I think they also need to re-evaluate their scouting department because let's face it, it needs some tweaking
sheila
Thu, Oct 23, 08 at 02:25 PM
enough about Burke and the Leafs, already. Who cares
Herb
Tue, Oct 28, 08 at 03:46 PM
Burke would be a good fit in TO. Cant happen tp soon
Add Your Comment
 
Your Name
 
Your Comment
 
 
The Rules:
 
Keep it clean, and stay on the subject or we might delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. You must have a javascript enabled browser to submit a comment.
 
 
 

Who is Canada's biggest threat?

Dave Waddell and Elliott Pap go head2head.

 
 
 
 
 
 
 

past head2head

 

Debating the deals

Wayne Scanlan and George Johnson go head2head.

 

Canadiens goalie situation...

Dave Stubbs and Pat Hickey go head2head.

 

Two views on head injuries...

Cam Cole and John MacKinnon go head2head.